Proton X50 atau X70: Mana Lebih Berbaloi?

Perbandingan lengkap X50 vs X70 2026. SUV Proton paling popular, harga, saiz, kos pemilikan sebenar, dan bila worth upgrade ke X70.

Diterbitkan: • Oleh

Jawapan Ringkas

X50 untuk value dan efficiency. X70 untuk size dan premium.

AspekProton X50Proton X70Pemenang
Harga entryRM85,800RM99,800X50
Engine1.5T 150/177hp1.5T 177hpX70 (consistent)
SizeB-segmentC-segmentX70
Boot space330L515LX70
Fuel consumption7.5 L/100km8.5 L/100kmX50
Rear spaceAdequateSpaciousX70
Ground clearance179mm178mmSimilar

Quick rule: Couple/small family → X50. Larger family/space priority → X70.

Perbandingan Harga

Proton X50

VarianHargaHighlights
1.5T StandardRM85,800Entry, 150hp
1.5T ExecutiveRM93,800Mid-spec
1.5T PremiumRM103,800High spec
1.5 TGDi FlagshipRM113,300177hp, top

Proton X70

VarianHargaHighlights
1.5 TGDi StandardRM99,800Entry
1.5 TGDi ExecutiveRM110,800Mid-spec
1.5 TGDi PremiumRM118,800High spec
1.5 TGDi Premium XRM123,800Premium+
1.5 TGDi FlagshipRM128,800Top spec

Price Gap

ComparisonX50X70Beza
EntryRM85,800RM99,800+RM14,000
FlagshipRM113,300RM128,800+RM15,500

X70 RM14,000-15,500 lebih mahal.

Perbandingan Spesifikasi

Enjin & Prestasi

AspekX50 StandardX50 FlagshipX70
Enjin1.5T 3-cyl1.5T 3-cyl1.5T 3-cyl
Kuasa150hp177hp177hp
Torque226Nm255Nm255Nm
Transmisi7DCT7DCT7DCT

X50 entry has less power (150hp). X50 Flagship and all X70 have 177hp.

Fuel Consumption

AspekX50X70
Spec6.5 L/100km7.5 L/100km
Real city8-9 L/100km9-11 L/100km
Real highway7-8 L/100km7.5-8.5 L/100km

X50 ~1-1.5 L/100km lebih jimat - significant difference.

Dimensi & Ruang

AspekX50X70
Panjang4,330mm4,519mm
Lebar1,800mm1,831mm
Tinggi1,609mm1,694mm
Wheelbase2,600mm2,670mm
Boot330L515L
Ground clearance179mm178mm

X70 19cm longer, 8.5cm taller, 56% more boot.

Perbandingan Features

Safety (Flagship vs Flagship)

FeatureX50 FlagshipX70 Flagship
Airbags66
ABS + EBD
ESC
AEB
ACC
LKA
BSM
360 camera
RCTA

Identical ADAS suite at flagship level.

Comfort & Convenience

FeatureX50 FlagshipX70 Flagship
Touchscreen10.25”12.3”
Digital cluster10.25”7”
Panoramic sunroof
BOSE audio
Ventilated seats
Power tailgate
Nappa leather
Wireless charging
Apple CarPlay

X70 has more premium features - BOSE, ventilated seats, power tailgate, Nappa leather.

Perbandingan Kos Pemilikan

Ansuran Bulanan (9 tahun, 3%)

ModelHargaAnsuran
X50 StandardRM85,800RM996
X50 FlagshipRM113,300RM1,315
X70 StandardRM99,800RM1,159
X70 FlagshipRM128,800RM1,496

Gaji Minimum

ModelAnsuranGaji Minimum
X50 StandardRM996RM6,000
X50 FlagshipRM1,315RM8,000
X70 StandardRM1,159RM7,000
X70 FlagshipRM1,496RM9,000

Fuel Cost (1,500km/bulan)

ModelConsumptionKos Bulanan
X508.5 L/100kmRM261
X7010 L/100kmRM308
BezaRM47/bulan

X70 RM47/bulan lebih untuk fuel = RM564/tahun.

Insurance (NCD 0%)

ModelAnnual
X50RM2,800
X70RM3,200
BezaRM400/tahun

Service Cost

AspectX50X70
Minor serviceRM200-350RM250-400
Major serviceRM450-700RM500-800
Yearly averageRM1,000-1,400RM1,200-1,600

X70 ~RM200/tahun lebih untuk servis.

Total Monthly Cost Comparison

ComponentX50 StandardX70 Standard
AnsuranRM996RM1,159
InsuranceRM230RM265
PetrolRM261RM308
ServisRM100RM115
TotalRM1,587RM1,847
Beza+RM260/bulan

X70 RM260/bulan lebih mahal = RM3,120/tahun.

Resale Value

After 5 Years

ModelPurchase5yr ValueRetain
X50RM85,800RM50,00058%
X70RM99,800RM55,00055%

Similar depreciation pattern - both lose ~45% in 5 years.

Kelebihan X50

1. Lower Price

RM14,000 savings at entry level = significant.

2. Better Fuel Efficiency

1-1.5 L/100km better = RM500-600/year savings.

3. Easier to Drive

  • Shorter = easier parking
  • More nimble in traffic
  • Less intimidating

4. Lower Running Costs

RM260/bulan cheaper = RM3,120/year.

5. Same Engine Available

X50 Flagship has identical 177hp engine as X70.

6. Sportier Character

  • Lower stance
  • Quicker handling
  • More fun to drive

Kelebihan X70

1. Significantly More Space

  • 19cm longer
  • 56% more boot (515L vs 330L)
  • More rear legroom

2. More Premium Features

  • BOSE audio system
  • Ventilated seats
  • Nappa leather
  • Power tailgate

3. Larger Screen

12.3” infotainment vs 10.25”.

4. Better for Families

More room for car seats, strollers, luggage.

5. More Commanding Presence

Bigger SUV = more road presence.

6. Consistent Power

All variants have 177hp. X50 entry only 150hp.

Bila Pilih X50?

✓ Pilih X50 Jika:

  1. Budget around RM85-100k

    • X70 entry stretching
    • X50 more comfortable fit

  2. Couple or small family

    • 2-3 people mostly
    • Don’t need massive boot
    • Space adequate

  3. City driving mainly

    • Compact size advantage
    • Easier parking
    • Nimble in traffic

  4. Fuel efficiency priority

    • Significant fuel savings
    • Long-term cost lower

  5. Want sporty character

    • Lower, quicker
    • More fun handling
    • Dynamic drive

  6. Monthly cost matters

    • RM260/bulan savings significant
    • Easier on cash flow

Bila Pilih X70?

✓ Pilih X70 Jika:

  1. Family of 4-5

    • More rear space
    • Car seats comfortable
    • Growing family

  2. Boot space essential

    • 515L vs 330L
    • Strollers, luggage
    • Sports equipment

  3. Want premium features

    • BOSE audio
    • Ventilated seats
    • Nappa leather
    • Power tailgate

  4. Highway/outstation heavy

    • More stable at speed
    • More comfortable long distance
    • More relaxed cruising

  5. Prefer larger vehicle

    • More commanding presence
    • Higher driving position
    • Feel more substantial

  6. Can afford +RM260/bulan

    • RM14k more upfront
    • RM3,120/year more running
    • Worth it for space/features

The Decision Matrix

X50 Standard vs X70 Standard

If Priority IsChoose
Lowest costX50
Fuel efficiencyX50
Compact sizeX50
More boot spaceX70
Rear passenger spaceX70
Premium featuresX70
Highway comfortX70

X50 Flagship vs X70 Standard

Interesting comparison - similar price:

ModelHargaPowerBootFeatures
X50 FlagshipRM113,300177hp330LTop X50
X70 StandardRM99,800177hp515LEntry X70

For RM13,500 less, X70 Standard gives:

  • Same power
  • 56% more boot
  • More space

But X50 Flagship gives:

  • Full ADAS
  • More features
  • Sportier

Depends on space vs features priority.

Case Studies

Case 1: Young Couple, No Kids

Profile: Two people, weekend trips, city living

FactorX50X70
Space needSufficientOverkill
ParkingEasierLarger
CharacterSportierMore relaxed

Verdict: X50. Don’t need X70 space.

Case 2: Family with 2 Kids

Profile: Parents + 2 young children, baby gear

FactorX50X70
Car seatsTight fitComfortable
Stroller + luggageStrugglesEasy
Rear spaceAdequateSpacious

Verdict: X70. Family needs justify upgrade.

Case 3: Solo Executive

Profile: Single, outstation travel, wants premium

FactorX50 FlagshipX70 Executive
PriceRM113,300RM110,800
FeaturesFullMid
Solo usePerfectOverkill

Verdict: X50 Flagship. Solo doesn’t need X70 space.

Soalan Lazim

X50 engine same as X70?

X50 Flagship (177hp) sama dengan semua X70. X50 Standard/Executive/Premium guna 150hp version.

X70 fuel consumption teruk?

More than X50 by 1-1.5 L/100km. Normal untuk larger SUV.

Mana lebih reliable?

Both sama - same platform, same engine, same manufacturer.

X50 boot cukup untuk family?

Untuk family of 3-4 dengan normal luggage, manageable. Family of 5 atau heavy packers, tight.

X70 worth RM14k more?

Jika perlukan space dan premium features, ya. Jika couple/small family, tidak perlu.

Kesimpulan

Quick Decision Guide

SituationRecommendation
Couple / 2-3 paxX50
Family 4-5 paxX70
City driving mainlyX50
Boot space priorityX70
Fuel efficiency focusX50
Premium features wantX70
Monthly cost sensitiveX50
Highway comfortX70
Sportier driveX50
More presenceX70

The Real Question

“Adakah saya perlukan extra space dan premium features enough untuk justify RM14,000 + RM260/bulan lebih?”

  • Couple/small family → No. X50 sufficient.
  • Growing family with kids → Yes. X70 worth it.
  • Want premium regardless → Yes. X70 delivers.

Related:

Bacaan Seterusnya

Panduan kereta:

Panduan gaji:

Perbandingan lain:

Panduan kewangan:

Perbandingan berdasarkan data Januari 2026. Harga tertakluk kepada perubahan.

Pasukan Stereng.my

Panduan keputusan pemilikan kereta untuk rakyat Malaysia. Kami tidak menjual kereta atau menerima komisen.

Ketahui metodologi kami →
Bebas Komisen Dikemaskini Berkala