SUV atau MPV: Mana Lebih Sesuai untuk Keluarga?

Perbandingan lengkap SUV vs MPV di Malaysia. 5-seater vs 7-seater, kos, ruang, dan bila setiap jenis lebih sesuai untuk keluarga anda.

Diterbitkan: • Oleh

Jawapan Ringkas

SUV untuk lifestyle dan 5 orang. MPV untuk keluarga besar dan 7 orang.

AspekSUVMPVPemenang
Seating5 (mostly)7MPV
Third row comfortTight/noneUsableMPV
Ground clearanceHighMediumSUV
Off-road capabilityBetterBasicSUV
Fuel efficiencyLowerBetterMPV
Boot (all seats up)400-500L150-200LSUV
Sliding doorsNoYes (some)MPV
Lifestyle imageTrendyPracticalSUV

Quick rule: Family ≤5 orang → SUV. Family 6-7 orang regular → MPV.

Definisi Ringkas

SUV (Sport Utility Vehicle)

Kereta dengan:

  • Ground clearance tinggi (~200mm)
  • 2-box design
  • Usually 5-seater (some 7)
  • Sporty/rugged image

Contoh popular: Proton X50, Perodua Ativa, Honda HR-V, Proton X70

MPV (Multi-Purpose Vehicle)

Kereta dengan:

  • Designed untuk passengers
  • 7-seater standard
  • Lower floor (easier access)
  • Practical/family-focused

Contoh popular: Perodua Alza, Proton Exora, Toyota Innova

Perbandingan Harga

ModelHargaSeatsSegment
Perodua AtivaRM62,5005B-SUV
Proton X50RM85,8005B-SUV
Honda HR-VRM114,8005B-SUV
Proton X70RM99,8005C-SUV
Honda CR-VRM155,0005/7C-SUV
ModelHargaSeatsSegment
Perodua AlzaRM62,5007B-MPV
Proton ExoraRM63,8007B-MPV
Toyota InnovaRM130,000+7/8C-MPV

Same-Price Comparison

BudgetSUV OptionMPV Option
~RM63,000AtivaAlza / Exora
~RM100,000X70-
~RM115,000HR-V-
~RM130,000+CR-VInnova

Nota: Di budget RM60-70k, anda boleh pilih antara SUV 5-seater atau MPV 7-seater.

Perbandingan Ruang

Seating Capacity

TypeStandardMaximum
SUV (compact)55
SUV (mid-size)57 (CR-V)
MPV78 (Innova)

Third Row Reality

ModelThird RowAdult Comfort
AtivaNoneN/A
X50NoneN/A
X70NoneN/A
CR-V (7-seat)AvailableTight
AlzaStandardTight
ExoraStandardOK
InnovaStandardGood

Reality check: Third row dalam Alza tight untuk adults. Exora dan Innova lebih selesa.

Boot Space Comparison

ModelAll Seats UpThird Row Folded
Ativa369LN/A
X50330LN/A
X70515LN/A
Alza180L529L
Exora205L580L

SUV menang bila semua seat up. MPV menang bila fold third row.

Perbandingan Kos Pemilikan

Ansuran Bulanan (9 tahun, 3%)

ModelHargaAnsuran
Ativa 1.0T XRM62,500RM726
Alza 1.5 XRM62,500RM726
X50 1.5T StandardRM85,800RM996
Exora 1.6T ExecutiveRM63,800RM741

Fuel Consumption

ModelEngineReal-worldKos/bulan
Ativa1.0T7-8 L/100kmRM185
Alza1.5 NA7-8 L/100kmRM185
X501.5T8-9 L/100kmRM210
Exora1.6T9-11 L/100kmRM245
X701.5T9-10 L/100kmRM235

Alza paling jimat among 7-seaters.

Insurance Comparison

ModelAnnual (NCD 0%)
AtivaRM2,200
AlzaRM2,200
X50RM2,800
ExoraRM2,400

Total Monthly Cost (Similar Price Point)

ComponentAtivaAlza
AnsuranRM726RM726
InsuranceRM160RM160
PetrolRM185RM185
ServisRM65RM60
TotalRM1,136RM1,131

Almost identical running cost. Decision should be based on needs, not cost.

Kelebihan SUV

1. Ground Clearance Tinggi

ModelGround Clearance
Ativa200mm
X50179mm
X70178mm
Alza165mm
Exora170mm

SUV handle:

  • Flood better
  • Speed bumps easier
  • Kampung roads
  • Unpaved terrain

2. Better Off-Road Capability

  • Higher approach/departure angles
  • Some have AWD option (X70)
  • Rougher terrain handling

3. Trendy/Lifestyle Image

  • Modern, sporty look
  • Popular choice currently
  • Outdoor activity compatible
  • Status symbol untuk some

4. Better Boot Access (5-seater)

Tanpa third row:

  • Full boot available always
  • No need to fold seats
  • 400-500L standard

5. Car Seat Installation Easier

Higher floor = less bending untuk install/remove child car seats.

Kelebihan MPV

1. True 7-Seater Capacity

  • Third row usable
  • Keluarga besar (5+ orang)
  • Carpool dengan jiran
  • Extended family trips

2. Lower Floor = Easier Access

  • Easier untuk elderly
  • Easier untuk kids
  • No climbing in/out
  • Less strain on knees

3. Sliding Doors (Some Models)

Toyota Alphard/Vellfire dan some MPVs:

  • Tight parking = no problem
  • Kids cannot bang adjacent cars
  • Easier loading passengers

4. Better Fuel Efficiency (Per Passenger)

Full load comparison:

  • X50 (5 pax): 9 L/100km = 1.8 L per person
  • Alza (7 pax): 9 L/100km = 1.3 L per person

MPV lebih efficient bila penuh.

5. More Headroom Throughout

Taller roof design = more comfortable untuk semua passengers.

6. Purpose-Built for Families

  • Rear blower standard
  • More cup holders
  • Fold-flat seats
  • Family-friendly features

Bila Pilih SUV?

✓ Pilih SUV Jika:

  1. Keluarga ≤5 orang

    • Tidak perlu third row
    • 5-seater cukup

  2. Jarang travel dengan 7 orang

    • Third row tidak penting
    • Boot capacity more valuable

  3. Sering pergi kawasan rural

    • Ground clearance penting
    • Unpaved roads common
    • Flood-prone area

  4. Prefer lifestyle/trendy look

    • SUV currently popular
    • Modern image

  5. Child car seats priority

    • Higher floor = easier installation
    • Less back strain

  6. Already have another car for big family trips

    • SUV untuk daily
    • Rent/borrow MPV bila perlu

Bila Pilih MPV?

✓ Pilih MPV Jika:

  1. Keluarga 6-7 orang regularly

    • Parents + 3-4 children
    • Grandmother/Grandfather ikut
    • Cannot fit in 5-seater

  2. Extended family trips kerap

    • Balik kampung dengan cousins
    • Family outings
    • Cannot split into 2 cars

  3. Elderly passengers kerap

    • Lower floor = easier access
    • Less climbing

  4. E-hailing (family service)

    • Airport runs
    • Large group pickups

  5. Carpool children

    • Send/pick anak + neighbours
    • School runs dengan multiple kids

  6. Prioritize passenger comfort over lifestyle

    • Function over form
    • Practical choice

Case Studies

Case 1: Young Couple + 1 Baby

Profile: Parents + infant, occasional grandparents

OptionSUV (Ativa)MPV (Alza)
Daily use3 people3 people
Grandparents joinTight (5)Easy (7)
Baby gearGood bootOK boot
Car seat installationEasierStandard

Verdict: SUV. Rarely need 7 seats. Car seat installation easier.

Case 2: Parents + 3 Kids

Profile: Family of 5, kids 4-12 years old

OptionSUV (X70)MPV (Alza)
Daily capacityExact fit (5)Room to spare
Friends joinCannotCan
Boot with 5GoodTight
Balik kampungJust family+ nenek boleh

Verdict: MPV. Growing family will appreciate extra capacity.

Case 3: Grandparents Kerap Ikut

Profile: Nuclear family + elderly parents regularly join

OptionSUV (HR-V)MPV (Exora)
Elderly accessClimb requiredEasier
6-7 passengersCannotYes
ComfortGood (5)OK (7)

Verdict: MPV. Elderly access dan capacity both favour MPV.

ModelHargaBest For
Perodua AtivaRM62,500Value compact SUV
Proton X50RM85,800Feature-rich SUV
Honda HR-VRM114,800Premium compact
Proton X70RM99,800Mid-size value
Honda CR-VRM155,000Premium 5/7-seater
ModelHargaBest For
Perodua AlzaRM62,500Value 7-seater
Proton ExoraRM63,800Power + space
Toyota InnovaRM130,000+Premium MPV

Soalan Lazim

SUV 7-seater ada tak?

Ada tapi limited. Honda CR-V 7-seater (RM175,000+). Third row sangat tight.

MPV ground clearance cukup ke?

Untuk jalan biasa, ya. Alza 165mm cukup untuk speed bumps dan flood ringan. Serious off-road, tidak.

Mana lebih selamat?

Bergantung model, bukan body type. Check ASEAN NCAP. Ativa, Alza, X50 semua ada ADAS.

Boleh ke MPV untuk 5 orang sahaja?

Boleh. Third row fold = boot besar. Tapi overkill jika selalu 5 orang sahaja.

SUV fuel consumption lebih tinggi?

Generally ya, sebab berat. Tapi Ativa vs Alza hampir sama sebab Alza engine lebih besar.

Anak kecil, SUV ke MPV?

SUV. Car seat installation easier (higher floor). Bila anak besar dan family grows, consider MPV.

Kesimpulan

Quick Decision Guide

SituationRecommendation
Family ≤5 orangSUV
Family 6-7 orangMPV
Occasionally 7 paxSUV + rent MPV
Elderly passengers kerapMPV
Child car seats prioritySUV
Kampung/flood areasSUV
Carpool kidsMPV
Budget ~RM63kEither (Ativa/Alza)
Lifestyle imageSUV

The Real Question

“Berapa kerap saya perlu bawa 6-7 orang?”

  • Jarang/never → SUV
  • Monthly → Consider MPV
  • Weekly → Definitely MPV

Bacaan Seterusnya

Panduan kereta:

Perbandingan lain:

Panduan kewangan:

Perbandingan berdasarkan data Januari 2026. Harga dan spesifikasi tertakluk kepada perubahan.

Pasukan Stereng.my

Panduan keputusan pemilikan kereta untuk rakyat Malaysia. Kami tidak menjual kereta atau menerima komisen.

Ketahui metodologi kami →
Bebas Komisen Dikemaskini Berkala