Honda HR-V atau Proton X50: Mana Lebih Berbaloi?

Perbandingan lengkap Honda HR-V vs Proton X50 2026. Harga, reliability, features, kos pemilikan, dan mana yang sesuai untuk anda.

Diterbitkan: • Oleh

Jawapan Ringkas

X50 untuk value dan features. HR-V untuk reliability dan resale.

AspekProton X50Honda HR-VPemenang
Harga entryRM85,800RM114,800X50 (-RM29,000)
Power150hp / 177hp121hpX50
FeaturesLebih banyakStandardX50
ReliabilityGoodExcellentHR-V
Resale valueGoodExcellentHR-V
Service costHigherLower (long-term)HR-V

Verdict: X50 untuk max value. HR-V untuk peace of mind.

Perbandingan Harga

Proton X50

VarianHargaEngineHighlights
1.5T StandardRM85,800150hpEntry
1.5T ExecutiveRM96,800150hpBetter features
1.5T PremiumRM103,300150hpSunroof
1.5 TGDI FlagshipRM113,300177hpFull spec

Honda HR-V

VarianHargaEngineHighlights
SRM114,800121hpEntry
ERM124,800121hpMid
VRM136,800121hpBetter features
RSRM146,800121hpFull spec

Beza Harga

PerbandinganBeza
Entry vs EntryRM29,000 (X50 lebih murah)
Top vs TopRM33,500 (X50 lebih murah)
X50 Flagship vs HR-V SRM1,500 (X50 lebih murah, more power)

RM29,000 savings dengan X50 boleh cover:

  • 4+ tahun petrol
  • Full accessories
  • Extended warranty
  • Emergency fund

Perbandingan Spesifikasi

Enjin & Prestasi

AspekX50 (1.5T)X50 FlagshipHR-V
Enjin1.5L Turbo1.5L Turbo1.5L NA
Kuasa150hp177hp121hp
Torque226Nm255Nm145Nm
Transmisi7DCT7DCTCVT
0-100~9.5s~7.9s~11s

Pemenang: X50 - Significantly lebih power (24-46% lebih).

Fuel Consumption

AspekX50HR-V
Spec (L/100km)6.46.0
Real-world7.5-9.07.0-9.0

Verdict: Similar - Real-world consumption hampir sama.

Dimensi & Space

AspekX50HR-V
Panjang4,330mm4,385mm
Lebar1,800mm1,790mm
Tinggi1,609mm1,592mm
Wheelbase2,600mm2,610mm
Boot432L437L

Verdict: Sama - Almost identical dimensions.

Perbandingan Features

Safety (Entry vs Entry)

FeatureX50 StandardHR-V S
Airbags66
AEB
Lane Keep
Adaptive Cruise
Blind Spot

Pemenang: HR-V - LKA standard dari entry.

Safety (Top vs Top)

FeatureX50 FlagshipHR-V RS
Airbags66
AEB
Lane Keep
Adaptive Cruise
Blind Spot

Pemenang: X50 - Blind spot monitor included.

Interior & Comfort

FeatureX50 ExecutiveHR-V E
Touchscreen10.25”8”
Digital clusterFullPartial
Leather seats
Sunroof
Wireless charger

Pemenang: X50 - Bigger screen, full digital cluster.

Interior Quality

AspectX50HR-V
MaterialsGoodVery good
Fit & finishGoodExcellent
FeelPremium for priceHonda quality
DurabilityGoodExcellent

Pemenang: HR-V - Honda build quality edge.

Kos Pemilikan

Ansuran Bulanan (9 tahun, 3%)

ModelHargaAnsuran
X50 StandardRM85,800RM996
X50 ExecutiveRM96,800RM1,124
X50 FlagshipRM113,300RM1,316
HR-V SRM114,800RM1,333
HR-V ERM124,800RM1,450
HR-V RSRM146,800RM1,705

Beza ansuran (entry): RM337/bulan

Kos Servis

AspekX50HR-V
Minor serviceRM200-350RM250-350
Major serviceRM400-700RM400-600
Yearly averageRM900-1,300RM850-1,200
5 tahun totalRM4,500-6,500RM4,250-6,000

Verdict: Similar - Slightly cheaper untuk HR-V long-term.

Kos Petrol (1,200km/bulan)

ModelConsumptionKos Bulanan
X508.2 L/100kmRM202
HR-V8.0 L/100kmRM197
BezaRM5/bulan

Insurans

ModelHargaAnnual (NCD 0%)
X50 ExecutiveRM96,800RM2,900
HR-V ERM124,800RM3,600
BezaRM700/tahun

Jumlah Kos Bulanan

KomponenX50 StandardHR-V S
AnsuranRM996RM1,333
InsuransRM242RM300
PetrolRM202RM197
ServisRM90RM85
TotalRM1,530RM1,915
Beza+RM385/bulan

HR-V kos RM385/bulan lebih = RM4,620/tahun = RM23,100 dalam 5 tahun.

Gaji Minimum

ModelHargaAnsuranGaji Minimum
X50 StandardRM85,800RM996RM5,500
X50 ExecutiveRM96,800RM1,124RM6,000
HR-V SRM114,800RM1,333RM7,000
HR-V ERM124,800RM1,450RM7,500

The Big Question: RM29,000 Worth It?

Apa HR-V Bagi yang X50 Tidak Ada?

  1. Honda badge - Established, respected
  2. Build quality - Slightly better fit/finish
  3. Reliability reputation - Proven track record
  4. Resale value - ~10% better retention
  5. Service network - More consistent experience

Apa X50 Bagi yang HR-V Tidak Ada?

  1. Lebih power - 150hp vs 121hp (24% lebih)
  2. Turbo response - More fun to drive
  3. Features lebih - Bigger screen, more tech
  4. RM29,000 savings - Significant amount
  5. Flagship option - 177hp available

Bila Pilih X50?

✓ Pilih X50 Jika:

  1. Value penting

    • RM29,000 savings
    • More features untuk ringgit

  2. Power matters

    • 150-177hp vs 121hp
    • Better overtaking
    • More confident highway

  3. Gaji RM5,500-7,000

    • X50 affordable
    • HR-V stretch budget

  4. Features enthusiast

    • Bigger screen
    • More tech
    • Turbo fun

  5. Tidak kisah resale

    • Plan keep lama
    • Tidak flip often

Bila Pilih HR-V?

✓ Pilih HR-V Jika:

  1. Reliability priority

    • Honda proven track record
    • Less worry

  2. Resale value penting

    • ~10% better retention
    • Easier to sell

  3. Honda brand matters

    • Established badge
    • Service consistency

  4. Gaji RM7,000+

    • Mampu premium
    • Not stretching

  5. Build quality important

    • Better fit/finish
    • Long-term durability

  6. Conservative choice

    • Safe pick
    • Fewer surprises

Reliability & Resale

Reliability

BrandRatingNotes
HondaExcellentProven, established
ProtonGoodImproved significantly, Geely platform

Resale Value (5 tahun)

ModelPurchase5yr ValueRetention
X50RM96,800~RM52,000~54%
HR-VRM124,800~RM75,000~60%

Verdict: HR-V - Better resale, easier to sell.

Total Cost of Ownership (5 tahun)

AspectX50 ExecutiveHR-V E
PurchaseRM96,800RM124,800
Running (5yr)RM25,000RM26,500
DepreciationRM44,800RM49,800
Net CostRM69,800RM76,300

X50 masih lebih jimat ~RM6,500 dalam 5 tahun walaupun HR-V resale lebih baik.

Head-to-Head: Similar Price

Budget RM115,000

X50 Flagship (RM113,300)HR-V S (RM114,800)
177hp121hp
Full ADAS + BSMLKA, AEB
Leather, sunroofBasic
Top specEntry spec

Verdict: X50 Flagship - Lebih value, lebih power, lebih features untuk harga sama.

Soalan Lazim

X50 reliable ke?

Yes. Geely/Volvo platform proven. Early batches had issues, later production better.

HR-V worth RM29,000 extra?

Untuk reliability seekers dan resale focus, mungkin ya. Untuk value seekers, tidak.

Mana lebih powerful?

X50 significantly. 150hp vs 121hp (24% lebih). Flagship 177hp (46% lebih).

Service mana lebih senang?

Both have good networks. Honda slightly more consistent experience.

Untuk family dengan anak?

Both OK. Similar size. X50 cheaper = more budget untuk family.

Kesimpulan

KriteriaPemenang
HargaX50
PowerX50
FeaturesX50
Build qualityHR-V
ReliabilityHR-V
Resale valueHR-V
Value for moneyX50
Peace of mindHR-V

Final Verdict:

Proton X50 untuk:

  • Value seekers
  • Power matters
  • Gaji RM5,500-7,000
  • Features enthusiast
  • Tidak kisah resale

Honda HR-V untuk:

  • Reliability priority
  • Resale value penting
  • Honda brand preference
  • Gaji RM7,000+
  • Conservative buyer

Recommendation:

  • Best value: X50 Executive (RM96,800)
  • Best peace of mind: HR-V E (RM124,800)
  • Best power-to-price: X50 Flagship (RM113,300)

Bacaan Seterusnya

Panduan kereta:

Panduan gaji:

Perbandingan lain:

Panduan kewangan:

Perbandingan berdasarkan data Januari 2026. Harga tertakluk kepada perubahan.

Pasukan Stereng.my

Panduan keputusan pemilikan kereta untuk rakyat Malaysia. Kami tidak menjual kereta atau menerima komisen.

Ketahui metodologi kami →
Bebas Komisen Dikemaskini Berkala