Jawapan Ringkas
Axia untuk bajet minimum. Myvi untuk balance terbaik. Beza harga RM15,000-21,000. Beza kos bulanan RM273. Tetapi selepas 5 tahun, Myvi sebenarnya RM1,370 lebih murah kerana resale value lebih tinggi.
| Aspek | Perodua Axia | Perodua Myvi | Pemenang |
|---|---|---|---|
| Harga entry (auto) | RM31,500 | RM46,500 | Axia |
| Enjin | 1.0L 67hp | 1.3/1.5L 98-105hp | Myvi |
| Segmen | A-segment | B-segment | Myvi |
| Boot | 260L | 277L | Myvi |
| Penggunaan minyak | 5.5 L/100km | 6.5 L/100km | Axia |
| Ruang belakang | Sempit | Mencukupi | Myvi |
| ADAS | ASA 2.0 (AV) | ASA 3.0 (H/AV) | Myvi |
| Resale 5 tahun | 57% | 75% | Myvi |
| Gaji minimum | RM2,500 | RM4,000 | Axia |
Peraturan cepat: Solo, bajet ketat, gaji bawah RM3,000 → Axia. Keluarga, highway, gaji RM4,000+ → Myvi.
Perbandingan Harga
Perodua Axia
| Varian | Harga | Highlights |
|---|---|---|
| 1.0 E (MT) | RM23,500 | Manual, paling murah |
| 1.0 G | RM31,500 | Auto, basic |
| 1.0 GXtra | RM33,500 | More features |
| 1.0 SE | RM36,000 | Sporty styling |
| 1.0 AV | RM38,600 | Full spec, ASA 2.0 |
Perodua Myvi
| Varian | Harga | Highlights |
|---|---|---|
| 1.3 G | RM46,500 | Entry, no PSDA |
| 1.3 G (PSDA) | RM48,500 | Cruise control |
| 1.5 X | RM50,900 | Bigger engine |
| 1.5 H | RM54,900 | ASA 3.0 |
| 1.5 AV | RM59,900 | Full spec |
Jurang Harga
| Perbandingan | Axia | Myvi | Beza |
|---|---|---|---|
| Entry (auto) | RM31,500 | RM46,500 | +RM15,000 |
| Top spec | RM38,600 | RM59,900 | +RM21,300 |
Myvi RM15,000-21,000 lebih mahal daripada Axia.
Perbandingan Spesifikasi
Enjin & Prestasi
| Aspek | Axia | Myvi 1.3 | Myvi 1.5 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Enjin | 1.0L 3-cyl | 1.3L 4-cyl | 1.5L 4-cyl |
| Kuasa | 67hp | 98hp | 105hp |
| Torque | 91Nm | 121Nm | 137Nm |
| Transmisi | 4AT | D-CVT | D-CVT |
| 0-100 | ~15s | ~12s | ~11s |
Myvi 1.5 adalah 57% lebih berkuasa dari Axia.
Perbezaan Kuasa Sebenar
| Situasi | Axia | Myvi |
|---|---|---|
| Bandar solo | Mencukupi | Lebih daripada cukup |
| Highway solo | Struggle 110km/j+ | Selesa |
| Penuh (4 orang) | Sangat perlahan | Mencukupi |
| Memotong | Perlu plan teliti | Yakin |
| Bukit + AC | Revvy, perlahan | Boleh handle |
Fuel Consumption
| Aspek | Axia | Myvi |
|---|---|---|
| Spec | 4.9 L/100km | 5.3 L/100km |
| Real city | 5.5-6.5 L/100km | 6.5-7.5 L/100km |
| Real highway | 5.0-6.0 L/100km | 5.5-6.5 L/100km |
Axia ~1 L/100km lebih jimat.
Dimensi & Ruang
| Aspek | Axia | Myvi |
|---|---|---|
| Panjang | 3,640mm | 3,910mm |
| Lebar | 1,620mm | 1,735mm |
| Tinggi | 1,525mm | 1,515mm |
| Wheelbase | 2,455mm | 2,500mm |
| Boot | 260L | 277L |
| Segment | A | B |
Myvi 27cm lebih panjang, 11cm lebih lebar - noticeably bigger.
Perbandingan Features
Safety
| Feature | Axia AV | Myvi AV |
|---|---|---|
| Airbags | 4 | 6 |
| ABS + EBD | ||
| ESC | ||
| AEB | ASA 2.0 | ASA 3.0 |
| ACC | ||
| LKA | ||
| Pedal misapplication |
Myvi has more airbags and better ADAS (ACC + LKA).
Keselesaan & Kemudahan
| Ciri | Axia AV | Myvi AV |
|---|---|---|
| Touchscreen | 6.9” | 9” |
| Apple CarPlay | ||
| Android Auto | ||
| Keyless entry | ||
| Push start | ||
| Auto climate | ||
| Rear AC vents | ||
| DVR |
Myvi jauh lebih banyak ciri walaupun pada perbandingan top spec.
Perbandingan Kos Pemilikan
Ansuran Bulanan (9 tahun, 3%)
| Model | Harga | Ansuran |
|---|---|---|
| Axia E (MT) | RM23,500 | RM273 |
| Axia G | RM31,500 | RM366 |
| Axia AV | RM38,600 | RM448 |
| Myvi 1.3 G | RM46,500 | RM540 |
| Myvi 1.5 AV | RM59,900 | RM695 |
Gaji Minimum
| Model | Ansuran | Gaji Minimum | Panduan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Axia E | RM273 | RM2,000 | Kereta gaji RM2,000 |
| Axia G | RM366 | RM2,500 | Kereta gaji RM2,500 |
| Myvi 1.3 G | RM540 | RM4,000 | Kereta gaji RM4,000 |
| Myvi 1.5 AV | RM695 | RM5,000 | Kereta gaji RM5,000 |
Pengiraan gaji minimum berdasarkan peraturan komitmen kereta tidak melebihi 25% daripada gaji. Baca panduan DSR untuk pengiraan lebih tepat.
Fuel Cost (1,200km/bulan)
| Model | Consumption | Kos Bulanan |
|---|---|---|
| Axia | 6.0 L/100km | RM148 |
| Myvi | 7.0 L/100km | RM172 |
| Beza | RM24/bulan |
Insurance (NCD 0%)
| Model | Annual |
|---|---|
| Axia | RM1,200 |
| Myvi | RM1,800 |
| Beza | RM600/tahun |
Service Cost
| Aspect | Axia | Myvi |
|---|---|---|
| Minor service | RM100-150 | RM150-250 |
| Major service | RM200-300 | RM300-450 |
| Yearly average | RM500-700 | RM800-1,000 |
Myvi ~RM300/tahun lebih untuk servis.
Jumlah Kos Bulanan Sebenar
| Komponen | Axia G | Myvi 1.3 G |
|---|---|---|
| Ansuran | RM366 | RM540 |
| Insurans | RM100 | RM150 |
| Petrol | RM148 | RM172 |
| Servis | RM50 | RM75 |
| Jumlah | RM664 | RM937 |
| % Gaji (min) | 27% (RM2,500) | 23% (RM4,000) |
| Beza | +RM273/bulan |
Myvi RM273/bulan lebih mahal = RM3,276/tahun. Tetapi sebagai % gaji minimum, kedua-dua sekitar 23-27% - dalam julat selamat.
Resale Value
After 5 Years
| Model | Purchase | 5yr Value | Retain |
|---|---|---|---|
| Axia G | RM31,500 | RM18,000 | 57% |
| Myvi 1.3 G | RM46,500 | RM35,000 | 75% |
Myvi retains significantly better:
- Axia loss: RM13,500
- Myvi loss: RM11,500
Myvi loses RM2,000 LESS despite higher purchase price.
Kelebihan Axia
1. Harga Paling Rendah
RM23,500 = kereta baru paling murah di Malaysia.
2. Kos Pemilikan Terendah
- Ansuran paling rendah
- Insurance paling murah
- Fuel paling jimat
- Servis paling murah
3. Saiz Paling Kompak
- Parking paling senang
- U-turn paling tight
- Bandar sesak = perfect
4. Fuel Efficiency
~1 L/100km better = RM288/tahun savings at 12,000km.
5. Perfect untuk Solo
Jika 90% masa bersendirian, Axia lebih daripada cukup.
Kelebihan Myvi
1. More Powerful
57% lebih power = highway, full load, AC semua lebih confident.
2. Better ADAS
ASA 3.0 dengan ACC dan LKA. Axia hanya AEB.
3. More Space
- 27cm lebih panjang
- Rear seat lebih comfortable
- Boot slightly bigger
4. More Features
Keyless, push start, auto climate, 9” screen, DVR.
5. Better Resale
75% vs 57% = Myvi actually loses less money.
6. More Refined
- Quieter cabin
- Better NVH
- More solid feel
- Better D-CVT vs old 4AT
7. 6 Airbags vs 4
Better crash protection.
Bila Pilih Axia?
✓ Pilih Axia Jika:
-
Budget sangat terhad
- Gaji bawah RM2,500
- Every RM counts
- Cannot afford RM15k more
-
Solo 90% of time
- Jarang bawa passenger
- Don’t need rear space
- Power not critical
-
City exclusive
- Never highway
- Short commutes
- Traffic jam daily
-
First car/learner
- Small = easier
- Cheap mistakes
- Learn basics first
-
Minimum financial commitment
- Lowest possible payment
- Emergency fund priority
- Other financial goals
Bila Pilih Myvi?
✓ Pilih Myvi Jika:
-
Bawa passenger regularly
- Family/friends
- Rear seat comfort matters
- More than solo use
-
Highway driving ada
- Need power to cruise
- Overtaking confidence
- Long distance comfort
-
Want better ADAS
- ACC for highway
- LKA for safety
- More comprehensive
-
Features matter
- Keyless entry
- Push start
- Auto climate
- Bigger screen
-
Resale consideration
- Actually loses less money
- Better long-term value
-
Can afford RM15k more
- RM273/bulan extra OK
- Worth the upgrade
Persoalan RM15,000
Apa Yang RM15,000 Tambahan Berikan
Upgrade dari Axia G ke Myvi 1.3 G:
| Peningkatan | Nilai |
|---|---|
| +31hp kuasa | Signifikan untuk highway |
| +45mm wheelbase | Ruang belakang lebih selesa |
| ADAS lebih baik | ASA 3.0 vs ASA 2.0 |
| Lebih banyak ciri | Keyless, push start, auto climate |
| Resale lebih baik | Jimat RM2,000+ selepas 5 tahun |
| Lebih refined | Kabin lebih senyap |
| 6 vs 4 airbag | Perlindungan lebih baik |
Berbaloi Ke?
Untuk solo bandar sahaja: Tidak berbaloi. Axia mencukupi. Untuk guna campuran dengan penumpang: Berbaloi. Myvi nilai jangka panjang lebih baik.
Contoh Kes
Kes 1: Pelajar/Part-timer, Pendapatan RM1,800
Profil: Solo, commute kampus, bajet ketat
| Faktor | Axia | Myvi |
|---|---|---|
| Kos bulanan | RM550 | RM823 |
| % pendapatan | 31% | 46% |
Keputusan: Axia. Myvi akan cause financial stress. Rujuk kereta untuk gaji RM1,500-2,000.
Kes 2: Eksekutif Muda, Gaji RM4,000
Profil: Commute + kadang outstation, kadang bawa penumpang
| Faktor | Axia | Myvi |
|---|---|---|
| Kos bulanan | RM664 | RM937 |
| % gaji | 17% | 23% |
| Highway | Struggle | Selesa |
| Penumpang | Sempit | Mencukupi |
Keputusan: Myvi. Berbaloi upgrade pada tahap gaji ini. Rujuk kereta untuk gaji RM4,000.
Kes 3: Pesara, Pendapatan Tetap
Profil: Penggunaan ringan, grocery, klinik
| Faktor | Axia | Myvi |
|---|---|---|
| Jarak rendah | Kelebihan | Overkill |
| Keperluan kuasa | Minimal | Tak perlu |
Keputusan: Axia. Penggunaan ringan tidak justify premium Myvi.
5-Year Total Cost
Axia G vs Myvi 1.3 G
| Item | Axia G | Myvi 1.3 G |
|---|---|---|
| 5yr payments | RM21,960 | RM32,400 |
| 5yr fuel | RM8,880 | RM10,320 |
| 5yr insurance | RM4,500 | RM6,750 |
| 5yr service | RM3,000 | RM4,500 |
| 5yr Total Out | RM38,340 | RM53,970 |
| 5yr Resale | RM18,000 | RM35,000 |
| Net 5yr Cost | RM20,340 | RM18,970 |
Myvi actually RM1,370 cheaper after resale!
The better resale value compensates for higher running costs.
Soalan Lazim
Myvi worth RM15k more?
Untuk mixed use dengan highway/passengers, ya. Untuk solo city, tidak.
Axia boleh highway?
Boleh, tapi struggles above 110. Solo tanpa AC, OK. Full load, very slow.
Mana lebih reliable?
Both sama reliable. Same Perodua quality.
Axia rear seat OK?
Untuk short trips, OK. Long trips atau 3 adults, very tight.
Should I stretch for Myvi?
Jangan sampai strain budget. Jika RM273 extra sebulan berat, stay with Axia.
Kesimpulan
Panduan Keputusan Pantas
| Situasi Anda | Cadangan | Sebab |
|---|---|---|
| Gaji < RM2,500 | Axia | Kos paling rendah |
| Solo 90% masa | Axia | Tak perlu ruang lebih |
| Bandar sahaja | Axia | Saiz kompak cukup |
| Kereta pertama | Axia | Mudah handle, murah untuk belajar |
| Bawa penumpang kerap | Myvi | Ruang lebih selesa |
| Highway driving | Myvi | Kuasa mencukupi |
| Mahu ADAS (ACC/LKA) | Myvi | ASA 3.0 lebih lengkap |
| Features penting | Myvi | Keyless, push start, DVR |
| Pertimbangkan resale | Myvi | 75% vs 57% selepas 5 tahun |
| Gaji RM4,000+ | Myvi | Mampu dan berbaloi |
Persoalan Sebenar
“Adakah RM15,000 tambahan berbaloi untuk kuasa, ruang, features, dan resale?”
- Solo bandar sahaja, bajet ketat → Tidak. Axia mencukupi.
- Guna campuran, bajet selesa → Ya. Myvi nilai jangka panjang lebih baik.
Bacaan Seterusnya
Panduan kereta:
Perbandingan lain:
- Axia atau Saga - Hatchback vs Sedan bajet
- Myvi atau City - Hatchback vs Sedan
Panduan gaji:
- Kereta untuk gaji RM2,500 - Range Axia
- Kereta untuk gaji RM4,000 - Range Myvi
Maklumat kewangan:
- Panduan DSR - Cara kira kemampuan sebenar
- Panduan Insurans - Kos insurans kereta
Perbandingan berdasarkan data Januari 2026. Harga tertakluk kepada perubahan.