Perodua Alza atau Proton Exora: Mana Lebih Berbaloi?

Perbandingan lengkap Perodua Alza vs Proton Exora 2026. MPV 7-seater, harga, power, kos pemilikan, dan mana yang sesuai untuk anda.

Diterbitkan: • Oleh

Jawapan Ringkas

Alza untuk platform moden dan ADAS. Exora untuk power dan harga lebih rendah.

AspekPerodua AlzaProton ExoraPemenang
Harga entryRM62,500RM63,800Exora (-RM1,300)
Power105hp (NA)140hp (Turbo)Exora
PlatformDNGA (2022)Old (2009)Alza
ADASAvailableTiadaAlza
Fuel efficiency7-8 L/100km9-11 L/100kmAlza
Third row spaceTightBetterExora

Verdict: Alza untuk moden dan efficient. Exora untuk power dan space.

Perbandingan Harga

Perodua Alza

VarianHargaHighlights
1.5 XRM62,500Entry, ASA 3.0
1.5 HRM68,000LED, smart entry
1.5 AVRM75,500Full ADAS, leather

Proton Exora

VarianHargaHighlights
1.6 Turbo ExecutiveRM63,800Entry, turbo
1.6 Turbo PremiumRM69,800Leather, more features

Beza Harga

PerbandinganBeza
Entry vs EntryRM1,300 (Exora lebih mahal)
Top vs TopRM5,700 (Alza AV lebih mahal)

Harga hampir sama - keputusan bukan berdasarkan bajet.

Perbandingan Spesifikasi

Enjin & Prestasi

AspekAlzaExora
Enjin1.5L NA1.6L Turbo
Kuasa105hp140hp
Torque138Nm205Nm
TransmisiD-CVTCVT
CharacterRefinedPunchy

Pemenang: Exora - 33% lebih power, turbo torque lebih baik.

Real-World Power Difference

ScenarioAlzaExora
EmptyAdequateMore than enough
Full load (7 pax)StrugglesHandles better
Highway climbRevvyMore relaxed
OvertakingPlan aheadConfident

Fuel Consumption

AspekAlzaExora
Spec (L/100km)5.57.5
Real-world (empty)7-89-10
Real-world (full)9-1011-13

Pemenang: Alza - 2-3 L/100km lebih jimat.

Platform & Technology

AspekAlzaExora
PlatformDNGA (2022)Old (2009)
Age3 tahun16 tahun
StructureModern, rigidDated
NVHBetterMore noise
HandlingImprovedAcceptable

Pemenang: Alza - Far more modern platform.

Dimensi & Space

AspekAlzaExora
Panjang4,425mm4,592mm
Lebar1,730mm1,749mm
Tinggi1,700mm1,747mm
Wheelbase2,750mm2,730mm
Boot (7 seats up)180L205L

Third Row Comparison:

AspectAlzaExora
LegroomTightBetter
HeadroomOKBetter
Adult comfortShort tripsAcceptable
AccessTumble 2nd rowTumble 2nd row

Pemenang: Exora - Physically larger, better third row.

Perbandingan Features

Safety

FeatureAlza XExora Executive
Airbags64
ABS
ESC
AEB
ADASASA 3.0
FeatureAlza AVExora Premium
Airbags64
AEB
ACC
LKA
360 Camera
BSM

Pemenang: Alza - ADAS suite comprehensive, lebih airbags.

Interior & Comfort

FeatureAlza HExora Premium
Touchscreen9”7”
Push start
Leather seats
Auto climate
Rear blower
USB ports

Verdict: Mixed - Alza better screen, Exora has leather earlier.

Kos Pemilikan

Ansuran Bulanan (9 tahun, 3%)

ModelHargaAnsuran
Alza 1.5 XRM62,500RM726
Alza 1.5 HRM68,000RM790
Alza 1.5 AVRM75,500RM877
Exora ExecutiveRM63,800RM741
Exora PremiumRM69,800RM811

Kos Servis

AspekAlzaExora
Minor serviceRM150-200RM200-300
Major serviceRM300-450RM400-550
Yearly averageRM650-850RM800-1,000
5 tahun totalRM3,250-4,250RM4,000-5,000

Pemenang: Alza - RM750-1,000 lebih jimat dalam 5 tahun.

Kos Petrol (1,300km/bulan)

ModelConsumptionKos Bulanan
Alza7.5 L/100kmRM200
Exora10 L/100kmRM267
BezaRM67/bulan

Yearly difference: RM804

Jumlah Kos Bulanan

KomponenAlza HExora Premium
AnsuranRM790RM811
InsuransRM170RM180
PetrolRM200RM267
ServisRM60RM75
TotalRM1,220RM1,333
Beza+RM113/bulan

Exora kos RM113/bulan lebih = RM1,356/tahun.

Gaji Minimum

ModelHargaAnsuranGaji Minimum
Alza 1.5 XRM62,500RM726RM4,000
Alza 1.5 HRM68,000RM790RM4,000
Exora ExecutiveRM63,800RM741RM4,000
Exora PremiumRM69,800RM811RM4,500

Bila Pilih Alza?

✓ Pilih Alza Jika:

  1. Mahu platform moden

    • DNGA 2022 vs 2009 platform
    • Better structure dan handling

  2. ADAS penting

    • Full suite di AV
    • AEB standard dari entry
    • Family safety priority

  3. Fuel efficiency priority

    • 2-3 L/100km lebih jimat
    • Long-term savings significant

  4. City driving mostly

    • Lighter, easier to maneuver
    • NA enough untuk bandar

  5. Prefer Perodua service

    • Wider network
    • Generally cheaper service

  6. Third row untuk anak sahaja

    • Tight third row acceptable
    • Tidak perlu adult comfort

Bila Pilih Exora?

✓ Pilih Exora Jika:

  1. Power penting

    • 140hp turbo vs 105hp NA
    • Full load lebih confident
    • Highway climbing better

  2. Third row untuk adults

    • Larger cabin
    • Better third row space
    • More comfortable untuk dewasa

  3. Often carry 7 passengers

    • Turbo handles load better
    • Less strain on engine
    • More relaxed driving

  4. Tidak kisah fuel consumption

    • Accept 9-11 L/100km
    • Power worth the fuel

  5. ADAS tidak priority

    • Basic safety sufficient
    • Experienced driver

  6. Prefer turbo character

    • Punchy response
    • More engaging drive

Head-to-Head: Similar Spec

Alza H (RM68,000) vs Exora Premium (RM69,800)

AspectAlza HExora Premium
PriceRM68,000RM69,800
Power105hp140hp
ADASASA 3.0 (AEB, LKA)None
Airbags64
Leather
Screen9”7”
Third rowTightBetter
Fuel7-8 L/100km9-11 L/100km

For safety focus: Alza H For power/space: Exora Premium

Reliability & Resale

Reliability

BrandRatingNotes
Perodua AlzaGoodNew platform, Daihatsu backing
Proton ExoraGoodProven, 16 years on market

Resale Value (5 tahun)

ModelRetain
Alza~55-60%
Exora~45-50%

Pemenang: Alza - Better resale, newer model.

Soalan Lazim

Alza cukup power untuk 7 orang?

City OK. Highway dengan full load akan struggle sikit, perlu plan overtaking.

Exora reliable ke after 16 tahun in market?

Yes, proven platform. Issues well-known dan parts available.

Mana third row lebih selesa?

Exora - Physically larger, more legroom dan headroom.

Turbo Exora ada problem?

CFE engine proven. Regular service penting. Turbo components perlu jaga.

Untuk keluarga besar mana lebih baik?

  • Frequently carry 7 adults: Exora
  • Mostly 5 + occasionally 7: Alza
  • Safety priority: Alza

Kesimpulan

KriteriaPemenang
PlatformAlza
PowerExora
ADAS/SafetyAlza
Fuel efficiencyAlza
Third row spaceExora
Running costAlza
Resale valueAlza
Full load abilityExora

Final Verdict:

Perodua Alza untuk:

  • Modern platform dan safety
  • ADAS penting
  • Fuel efficiency matters
  • Third row mostly untuk anak
  • City driving majority

Proton Exora untuk:

  • Power untuk full load
  • Larger third row
  • Frequently carry 7 adults
  • Highway/outstation kerap
  • Turbo character preferred

Recommendation:

Alza 1.5 H (RM68,000) untuk most families - modern, safe, efficient. Exora Premium (RM69,800) jika power dan space untuk adults essential.

Bacaan Seterusnya

Panduan kereta:

Panduan gaji:

Perbandingan lain:

Panduan kewangan:

Perbandingan berdasarkan data Januari 2026. Harga tertakluk kepada perubahan.

Pasukan Stereng.my

Panduan keputusan pemilikan kereta untuk rakyat Malaysia. Kami tidak menjual kereta atau menerima komisen.

Ketahui metodologi kami →
Bebas Komisen Dikemaskini Berkala